How SmarterStats compares to other web analytics tools
While script-based analytics products have their place, server-side analytics provide data that can be excluded from a script-based service due to policy, security, and browser restrictions. SmarterStats reports from your web server logs, on servers you control. These pages compare it, fact by fact, with the tools people ask us about most.
At a glance
Script-based
| Product | Collects data from | Where it runs | Spiders and bots | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SmarterStats | Your web server logs | Your Windows server, reading logs from Windows and Linux web servers | Reported separately from people | Actively developed |
| Google Analytics | A JavaScript tag on each page | Cloud | Known bots removed, with no report of how much was removed | Cloud service |
| Matomo | A JavaScript tracker by default; a Python command-line script can import logs | Matomo Cloud, or a self-hosted PHP application | Left out of log imports by default | Cloud service and self-hosted software |
| Plausible | A JavaScript snippet on each page | Plausible Cloud, or the self-hosted Community Edition | Bots that don't run scripts aren't recorded | Cloud service; Community Edition with community support only |
| Cloudflare Web Analytics | A JavaScript beacon on each page | Cloudflare | Bots that don't run scripts aren't recorded | Cloud service |
Server-side
| Product | Collects data from | Where it runs | Spiders and bots | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SmarterStats | Your web server logs | Your Windows server, reading logs from Windows and Linux web servers | Reported separately from people | Actively developed |
| WebLog Expert | Web server logs | A desktop application | No new spider definitions | Development and sales discontinued |
| AWStats | Web server logs | Perl and CGI; on Windows, configured under IIS | Robot definitions last updated in 8.0 | Final release (8.0); no longer actively developed |
Data current as of November 2026. Information obtained via each vendor's website.
Script-based analytics
A tracking script counts what it can see in the browser. SmarterStats counts every request your servers logged, and the two can run side by side.
Google Analytics
GA4 samples large queries, withholds rows under data thresholds and removes known bots. SmarterStats builds every report from every logged request.
SmarterStats vs. Google AnalyticsMatomo
Matomo is built around a JavaScript tracker, with a self-hosted option. Its log import is a Python command-line script that leaves bots out by default. SmarterStats is an installed log analyzer for up to 30,000 sites.
SmarterStats vs. MatomoPlausible
Plausible's documentation says strict blockers typically hide 5% to 25% of visitors without a proxy, and its self-hosted edition has community support only. SmarterStats adds nothing to your pages.
SmarterStats vs. PlausibleCloudflare Web Analytics
Cloudflare's FAQ says ad blockers can block its beacon, and accounts are limited to 10 sites that aren't proxied through Cloudflare. SmarterStats reports on every site whose logs it reads.
SmarterStats vs. Cloudflare Web AnalyticsLog analyzers
WebLog Expert
Development and sales have been discontinued. SmarterStats reads the same IIS and Apache logs, with an edition for every WebLog Expert edition.
SmarterStats vs. WebLog ExpertAWStats
Version 8.0 is the author's last release, and new Plesk installs no longer include it. SmarterStats installs natively on Windows Server.
SmarterStats vs. AWStatsLearn more about server-side analytics
Analytics without JavaScript
Visitors who block scripts, bots, failed requests and direct downloads all appear in your logs. See what a tracking script can't count.
Web analytics without JavaScriptWhere scripts aren't allowed
For government, education and finance sites that can't load third-party scripts, and intranets that never face the internet.
Government and regulated sitesIIS log analyzer
Import sites straight from IIS and turn W3C Extended and IIS legacy logs into traffic, visitor, bot and server health reports.
IIS log analyzerWhat to check in any comparison
- Where the data comes from: a script in the browser, or the logs your servers already write.
- What's left out: visitors who block scripts, bots, server errors and direct downloads.
- Where your data lives, and who decides how long it's kept.
- How many sites one license or account covers, and what it costs as you add more.
- Whether the product is still developed, with new builds and updated spider and bot definitions.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a web analytics tool that doesn't use JavaScript?
Yes. SmarterStats builds its reports from the logs your web servers already write, so there's no tag to add to your pages and nothing for an ad blocker to stop.
Does SmarterStats replace Google Analytics?
It can. SmarterStats reports on every request that reaches your server, including bots, server errors and visitors who block scripts. If you also want real-time stats, or in-browser details such as clicks and screen size, a script-based tool can run as a complement to SmarterStats.
Is SmarterStats still in development?
Yes. We build, update and support SmarterStats ourselves, and publish release notes for every build.
How current are these comparisons?
Each comparison page says where its competitor facts came from and the month they were checked. If something is out of date, contact us and we'll correct it.