Skip to content

SmarterStats vs. Google Analytics 4

Google Analytics 4 counts what its JavaScript tag can see and what each visitor's browser and consent settings allow. SmarterStats counts every request your web servers log, with no sampling, no thresholds and no tag on your pages, and keeps the data on your own servers.

While script-based analytics products have their place, server-side analytics provide data that can be excluded from a script-based service due to policy, security, and browser restrictions.

Side by side

FeaturesGoogle Analytics 4SmarterStats
Data sourceA JavaScript tag on each pageYour web server logs
Visitors who block scriptsNot countedCounted
SamplingQueries over 10 million events are sampled on standard propertiesNone. Every request is in every report
Data thresholdsRows are withheld by system-defined thresholds you can't adjustNone
Data retentionEvent and user-level data kept 2 or 14 months on standard propertiesYou decide
Bots and crawlersKnown bots removed automatically, with no report of how much was removedReported separately from people
Server errors and status codesNot in standard reportsReported
Consent settingsWith basic consent mode, the tag is blocked until the visitor agreesNothing runs in the browser
Intranet sitesRequires every visitor's browser to reach GoogleRuns inside your network
Where your data livesCloudYour servers

Data current as of November 2026. Information obtained via the Google website (Google Analytics Help).

What GA4 can't see

A script reports when it loads, runs and is allowed to send data. Visitors who use an ad blocker, turn off JavaScript or decline consent drop out of GA4's numbers, along with the bots Google removes and the requests that failed before the page loaded. Your server logged all of them, and SmarterStats reports on all of them.

Web analytics without JavaScript

No sampling, no thresholds

GA4 standard properties sample queries above 10 million events and withhold rows when data thresholds apply. SmarterStats builds every report from every logged request, so the numbers don't change with the size of your date range or the filters you add.

Drill into any page, path, referrer or query

Your history, kept as long as you want

GA4 standard properties keep event and user-level data for 2 or 14 months. With SmarterStats, your logs and reports stay on your servers for as long as you keep them, and you set the retention for each site.

Use GA4 as a complement

GA4 reports on in-browser events such as clicks and scrolls. If your marketing team needs that, keep the tag on your public pages and use SmarterStats for the complete count of what your servers delivered, for bots and server health, and for every site GA4 can't reach.

  • Every request your servers logged, including visitors who block scripts
  • Spider and bot reports, separate from human visitors
  • Status codes and server errors, with Site Tuning to find broken links and slow pages
  • Intranet and internal sites that never face the internet

What SmarterStats costs

EditionSitesPrice
Free1$0
Professional50 to 2,500From $525 for 50 sites
Enterprise50 to 30,000From $775 for 50 sites

Free includes every report and tool for one website. To test more than one site, contact us for a 30-day trial license.

Frequently asked questions

Does SmarterStats replace Google Analytics?

It can. SmarterStats reports on every request that reaches your server, including bots, server errors and visitors who block scripts. If you also want real-time stats, or in-browser details such as clicks and screen size, a script-based tool can run as a complement to SmarterStats.

Do I need to remove the GA4 tag?

No. SmarterStats doesn't touch your pages, so both can run at the same time.

Does SmarterStats sample data?

No. Every report is built from every logged request, whatever the size of your date range or the filters you add.

Does SmarterStats set cookies?

No. SmarterStats sets no cookies and runs no code in the browser. Your logs still record IP addresses, so they fall under the same data policies as your other server logs.

What does SmarterStats cost?

SmarterStats Free covers one site. Professional starts at $525 and Enterprise at $775, for 50 sites.

Every request, on your own servers