Logging is on, double checked the directory it goes to. When smarter stats auto-detects the log directory for the web site, it is the correct directory.
There is only one log file in the directory, which is the day the web site was started. Smarter collects the data for that one log. I have checked the permissions on the web sites and on the directories, compared the setup in IIS for all sites and they seem to be identical.
Three web sites collect the data correctly, two do not.
Thanks,
James